The Tortured Logic of Jonathon Milne

Letter to the editor of the Sunday Star Times. Responds to an article (editorial) by Jonathon Milne in the Star Times regarding Cuba sanctions, TPPA, social housing, etc.

The Editor
The Sunday Star Times
13 January, 2016

Dear Editor:

There is a similar intent and effect, namely domination, between the old trade embargo of Cuba by USA and the restrictions on democratic sovereignty of the proposed TPPA. In the case of the now lessoned embargo on Cuba it was a political domination by the big bully neighbour with economic implications, while with the TPPA it is the domination by the narrow profit interests of big bully global corporations with political implications.

Jonathon Milne (editorial 10 Jan) tries to say both of these conflicting developments are good, even consistent with each other. Trying to follow the mind of Mr Milne through the tortured logic of his convoluted paragraphs makes for harrowing reading. For example, misrepresenting concerns about the government chipping away at its own responsibility for social housing allows him to use the government’s claim those concerns are “building walls” to foreign investment (the common ‘straw man’ attack). Then ignoring the fundamental reality of the global growing gap between affluent and poor, which has largely been manufactured through the race to the bottom (wages) of so called “free trade” globalization, he suggests the TPPA would break down barriers holding down “impoverished workers in developing nations”.


Richard Keller
13 Endeavour St.
Wellington 6022


Commenting has now closed on this article.

The Indymedia Network

Latin America
United States
East Asia
South Asia
West Asia